Top Magic Shows in New York City
If you're seeking mind-blowing illusions and unforgettable performances in NYC, these top magic shows will leave you amazed. As a corporate event magician in the NYC area, I'm often asked, “What's the best magic show in NYC?" or "Who are the top magicians and mentalists performing right now?" (I’m also often asked “Do you know Oz Pearlman?”!)
To help you navigate New York’s magic scene, I've compiled a list of exceptional shows and performers (including myself!) that offer unique and unforgettable experiences. Whether you prefer intimate sleight-of-hand acts or grand illusions, there's something here for everyone. Here are the best magic shows, magicians & mentalists in New York City:
Architect of The Mind
Mentalist Fred Berthelot
Location: Private Engements Only
Website fredbert.com
Elevate your private and corporate events in NYC with mind-blowing mentalism and magic. Fred Berthelot, “Architect of The Mind,” designs and builds interactive performances that engage, connect, and leave lasting impressions. From milestone celebrations to corporate gatherings, his tailored shows spark conversation, build bonds, and ensure an unforgettable experience. Whether it’s a high-end party or retreat, Fred transforms any event into a memorable occasion.
Speakeasy Magick
Location: Flatiron
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: mckittrickhotel.com/events/speakeasy-magick/
Hosted by Todd Robbins, this immersive magic experience takes place at individual tables, where talented magicians move from group to group, showcasing astonishing close-up magic. Brief stage performances round out the evening, but it's the intimate, table-side tricks that steal the show. Robbins himself calls it "magic speed dating," and it's sure to leave you both surprised and entertained.
Magic After Hours
Location: Midtown West
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: magicafterhours.com
This intimate show takes place after hours at Tannen's, New York's oldest magic shop. Magician Noah Levine guides guests through a charming mix of classic magic tricks, historical insights, and plenty of audience engagement. With only 20 seats available per show, it's a rare and memorable experience.
69 Atlantic
Location: Brooklyn Heights
Rating: 4/5 Stars
Run Time: Until December 27, 2025
Website: artofplay.com
This close-up magic series unfolds in a hidden venue behind the Art of Play curiosity shop. Each performance features a rotating lineup of magicians, ensuring a unique experience every visit. Past performers have included David Williamson, Alexandra Duvivier, and Paul Gertner.
Urban Illusions
Location: East Village
Run Time: Until December 27, 2025
Website: urbanillusionsnyc.com
Illusionist Hayden Childress crafts an immersive experience for just 20 spectators at a time. Focused more on mood than spectacle, the show creates an enchanting, dreamlike atmosphere ideal for fans of subtle and sophisticated magic.
Monday Night Magic: Close-Up & In-Person
Location: Greenwich Village
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: mondaynightmagic.com
This long-running series has showcased a rotating lineup of professional magicians for over 20 years. With a casual and comedic vibe, this event offers an old-school magic experience that feels warm, welcoming, and packed with surprises.
Magic, Unlocked
Location: Upper East Side
Run Time: Until March 11, 2025
Website: keysandheels.com
Hosted inside a stylish speakeasy hidden behind the Keys & Heels storefront, this monthly magic show features a rotating lineup of skilled magicians curated by Mark Clearview. The intimate setting and interactive nature make it a standout option.
Chamber Magic
Location: Midtown East
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: chambermagic.com
Known as the "Millionaires' Magician," Steve Cohen presents an elegant evening of magic in the luxurious Madison Room of the Lotte New York Palace. Dressed in a tuxedo, Cohen impresses with masterfully polished routines, including his signature "Think-a-Drink" act and a mesmerizing levitation sequence. Formal attire is required, adding to the upscale ambiance.
The Magician
Location: Gramercy
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: danwhite.tv
Dan White's blend of mentalism, card tricks, and illusions has made him a popular fixture on Jimmy Fallon's Tonight Show. His sophisticated performances, often staged in a cozy and stylish setting, make this show an ideal date-night experience.
The Parlour of Deceptions
Location: Greenwich Village
Run Time: Ongoing
Website: salmagundi.org
Magician Daniel Roy offers a sophisticated evening of mentalism and sleight-of-hand magic in the elegant Salmagundi Club. Blending storytelling with impressive illusions, Roy's performance draws on classic techniques for a memorable evening. Cocktail attire is required.
Mindplay
Location: West Village
Run Time: Until April 20, 2025
Website: vinnydeponto.com
Vinny DePonto combines audience participation with mentalist tricks in this immersive theatrical experience. DePonto’s masterful magic is matched by his raw honesty, using humor and personal stories to create a shared sense of vulnerability with his audience. A captivating performance.
Broadway Magic Hour
Location: Hell's Kitchen
Run Time: Until December 27, 2025
Website: broadwaymagichour.com
Perfect for families, this magic show combines comedy and illusions designed to captivate young audiences. Hosted by Jim Vines and Carl Mercurio, it's an affordable and entertaining way to spend an afternoon in Times Square.